Reservation was intended to empower the needy, not to preserve privilege by birth. A fair, need-based Reservation to All is the way to achieve equitable distribution, social justice and Viksit Bharat @ 2047
Dr. Haribhau Rambhau Bhapkar
Every year, when results for high level competitive examinations such as NEET, JEE, CUET, UPSC and state recruitment are declared across India, two kinds of reactions are seen in our homes. One family celebrates because their child has secured a seat. Another family, often equally deserving, quietly asks a painful question: Was the process fair?That question is at the heart of India’s reservation debate. It is emotional, it is political, and above all, it is constitutional. Reservation is not a favour granted by the state. It is a promise made by the Constitution to those who were historically denied opportunity that they would be brought into the dynamics of nation-building and progress. But after more than seven decades, we must ask with honesty and without bitterness: Has the system kept that promise? Has it reached the truly needy? Or has it become uneven, rigid, and in urgent need of redefinition?This article is not a call to abolish reservation. It is a call to reform it to make it more equitable, more need-based, and more justifiable to all sections of society. If India is to become Viksit Bharat by 2047, we cannot carry forward a system based on inborn privilege rather invite talent to contribute for the nation development and moreover, to live in India. We must move to equitable distribution.
1. The Constitutional Foundation: India’s reservation policies are enshrined in the Constitution under Articles 15(4) and 16(4) for educational institutions and public employment respectively. These provisions allow the state to make special provisions for the advancement of Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes.The percentages vary from state to state. In education, reservation extends from primary schools to universities. In employment, government jobs have reserved positions for SCs, STs, OBCs and, more recently, EWS candidates. The intention of the framers was clear. Reservation was to be a tool of social justice, not a tool of permanent division. It was to correct historical discrimination, not to create new forms of discrimination.
2. Where The System Strains Today: In practice, reservation has faced criticism across India from Uttar Pradesh to Tamil Nadu, from Maharashtra to the North-East.
a) Impact On Meritocracy: When selection is based on factors other than merit, it can affect the quality of institutions and public services. A doctor, an engineer, a teacher or a judge must be competent, because their competence affects the lives of others.
b) Creamy Layer Problem: Within every reserved category, there are families who have now become socially and economically advanced. If they continue to take benefits, the poorest within the same category remain excluded generation after generation.
c) Stigmatisation: Reservation was meant to remove stigma. Yet in many classrooms it has unintentionally created new labels, resentment, and damage to inter-group relations.
d) Administrative Challenges: Ensuring benefits reach intended beneficiaries, preventing misuse and fraud, and maintaining transparency remain difficult especially for students from remote villages, tribal belts, border areas and urban slums where verification is weak and awareness is low.
e) Inadequate Representation Of Other Marginalised Groups: A system focused only on caste-based categories can neglect religious minorities, women, persons with disabilities, and economically weak families in so-called forward communities who also face real disadvantage.
f) Long-term Dependency: Without parallel measures to enhance skills, education and capability, reservation alone can lead to dependency rather than empowerment.
These drawbacks do not mean reservation has failed. They mean reservation needs to evolve towards Reservation to All who are truly needy.
“Moving beyond the binary deadlock of extension versus abolition, a modern reservation policy can evolve into a dynamic, data-driven framework that harmonizes social need with merit. Anchored in the unifying spirit of Articles 15 and 16, this vision for Viksit Bharat @ 2047 champions a mandatory creamy layer, single-category eligibility, proportionate share distribution, and a dedicated 50% open-merit pool. By shifting the paradigm from divisive quota politics to an ethics of justice, this approach replaces inherited privilege with equitable opportunity—empowering every citizen to contribute meaningfully to nation-building.”
3. A Proposal |Reservation To All: We propose a simple, transparent and equitable formula that can be applied uniformly across India:Let N be the total population in India. Let C1, C2, C3… Cn be thepercentage of populations of the categories G1, G2, G3… Gn respectively.Divide 50% reservation among all categories by assigning (1/2) x Ci percentage quota to the ith category.The remaining 50% must be open for all meritorious students of all categories.A candidate must be considered in only one group either in the reserved group or in the open group, not in both.
4. Why This Matters For Viksit Bharat @ 2047: India is a diverse nation with different languages, regions, faiths, castes and economic conditions. We have students in Delhi and Mumbai with access to coaching and internet, and students in rural Bihar, tribal Odisha, interior Maharashtra, and remote North-East who walk kilometres to school. We have families who have benefited from reservation for three generations, and families who have never benefited at all.For our youth, government jobs and professional seats are not just careers, they are hope. When the system appears impervious or unfair, that hope turns into frustration, and frustration turns into division.A proportionate, income-linked Reservation to All would do three things for India:
1) It would protect the truly disadvantaged in every community, in every state North, South, East, West and North-East.
2) It would protect merit by keeping 50% genuinely open to all.
3) It would reduce inter-group tension by making distribution clear, proportionate and data-based.
Viksit Bharat @ 2047 cannot be built on inherited privilege. It can only be built on talent, hard work and equal opportunity. A developed India needs doctors from every village, engineers from every community, teachers from every background selected because they are needy and meritorious, not because they were born into advantage or disadvantage.
5. From Inborn Privilege To Equitable Distribution: Reservation should not be an unending debate about extension versus abolition. It should be a living policy reviewed with data, guided by income and need, and balanced with merit. If we make the creamy layer compulsory, restrict a candidate to one category, and divide the reserved share proportionately while keeping 50% open, we can move from a politics of reservation to an ethics of justice. That is the true spirit of Articles 15 and 16, not to divide society, but to unite it by giving every citizen a fair opportunity to contribute to nation-building. Reservation to All is not a slogan. It is the path from inborn privilege to equitable distribution, pragmatic journey from social justice to Viksit Bharat @ 2047.
(The author is Head-Department of Mathematics at Central university of Kashmir. The views, opinions and conclusions expressed in this article are those of the author and aren’t necessarily in accord with the views of “Kashmir Horizon”)
[email protected]





