“Seizing thousands of kilograms of rotten meat in Budgam has exposed major flaws in Kashmir’s food safety system. While officials deserve credit for intercepting the consignment, the incident highlights an overreliance on sporadic raids over consistent market regulation.”
The seizure of thousands of kilograms of rotten and unhygienic meat at Budgam Railway Station has once again exposed serious shortcomings in Kashmir’s food safety and market regulation system. While the Food Safety Department and police deserve appreciation for intercepting the consignments, the incident raises a much larger question: why does the government continue to depend on occasional raids when the institutional mechanism meant to regulate markets and ensure remains weakened? The recent seizure of approximately 1,600 kilograms of unfit buffalo meat, followed by the interception of another consignment reportedly weighing around 2,000 kilograms, is a disturbing reminder of the risks consumers face. The quantities involved point towards a supply-chain problem that requires more than the seizure and destruction of contaminated material. It demands sustained surveillance, accountability and an effective mechanism. At the centre of this concern is the absence of the suspension of the enforcement wing of Food Civil Supplies & Consumer Affairs (FCS&CA) Department which for more than five decades played an important role in market checking and monitoring commercial establishments. The wing was suspended after the legal framework governing its functioning was no longer in place. However, despite the change in the political and administrative environment, the mechanism has not been effectively revived. The result is an institutional vacuum at a time when market regulation and consumer protection require greater attention. The suspension of the enforcement wing of Food Civil Supplies & Consumer Affairs (FCS&CA) Department is not merely an administrative issue. It directly affects the government’s capacity to maintain regular checks on markets, monitor commercial practices and ensure compliance with prescribed standards. Occasional inspections by the Food Safety Department cannot substitute for a dedicated and adequately empowered arrangement. The repeated discovery of unsafe food products raises questions about how effectively the existing system is monitoring the movement and sale of goods. The responsibility for this situation cannot be placed on employees who are expected to perform their duties within the limits of the available legal and administrative framework. Officials cannot exercise powers that are not legally vested in them. If the earlier Wing was suspended because the necessary statutory provisions were unavailable, the solution lies in restoring the legal framework, not in leaving the institution dysfunctional indefinitely. The elected government must explain why this important mechanism has not been revived. A popular government is expected to be responsive to public concerns and strengthen institutions that directly affect people’s everyday lives. Consumer protection and market regulation should not remain neglected merely because the process of restoring a mechanism requires legislative or administrative intervention. If the existing law does not adequately provide for the functioning of the enforcement wing of Food Civil Supplies & Consumer Affairs (FCS&CA) Department, the government can examine the relevant provisions, introduce necessary amendments or frame an appropriate legal mechanism to restore it.
“Merely destroying seized rotten meat and issuing official promises is insufficient to ensure food safety in Kashmir. The government must prosecute offenders and shift from reactive crackdowns to proactive, permanent market regulation. Specifically, authorities need to immediately restore the suspended enforcement wing of the Food, Civil Supplies & Consumer Affairs (FCS&CA) Department with proper legal backing, adequate staffing, and regular inspections to protect consumers before unsafe products reach the market.”
There is no justification for allowing an important arrangement to remain suspended when the government has the authority to initiate corrective measures. The problem is further aggravated by the shortage of manpower in the departments concerned. Food safety officials are required to inspect markets, verify licenses, collect samples, monitor transportation and storage conditions and respond to complaints. Expecting a limited workforce to supervise an expanding commercial network is unrealistic. The government must fill vacancies, provide technical support and strengthen field-level. The rotten meat episode also demands a comprehensive investigation into the entire supply chain. Authorities must identify the suppliers, transporters and intended recipients, examine cold-chain arrangements and establish whether similar consignments have previously entered the Valley. Action should not stop at destroying the seized meat; those responsible must be identified and prosecuted under applicable laws. More importantly, the government must recognise that food safety cannot be ensured through reactive policing alone. A permanent mechanism is essential to regulate markets, prevent the circulation of unsafe products and protect consumers from exploitative commercial practices. Every time a large consignment of rotten meat is seized, officials promise strict action. But promises and press statements cannot replace institutional capacity. The real test of governance is whether authorities can prevent such consignments from reaching the market in the first place. The suspension of the enforcement wing of Food Civil Supplies & Consumer Affairs (FCS&CA) Department Wing has left an important gap that needs immediate attention. Restoring it through an appropriate legal framework, providing adequate manpower and ensuring regular market inspections must become priorities. Kashmir’s consumers deserve more than occasional crackdowns. They deserve a functioning system that protects their health, regulates markets and holds offenders accountable. Destroying rotten meat is necessary, but restoring the machinery that can prevent its arrival is far more important. The Government must act before another consignment exposes the same institutional failure.

